Harbor Freight Jack Stands: Actually dangerous, OR example of Social Media Misinformation/Exaggeration? Recall and Post-Recall units.

 

By now, EVERYONE who cares a bit about cars knows the Harbor Freight JACK-STAND recall. I’ve seen probably 50 memes in each Facebook group I’m on. Harbor Freight is offering a store value gift card, OR a replacement with an updated model.

The Recall comes from a failure of the center post not having large enough “Teeth”, allowing the jack to ratchet-down unexpectedly… obviously a huge issue, and quite dangerous… but not the catastrophic “break in half and explode” that many are expecting. However, shortly after Harbor Freight started swapping for “updated” models a curious photo of a split stand surfaced.

*See bottom of post for updated photos of the split stand


The Recall:

Below is the recall graphic. There is one important distinction that has been missed by many: The recall only includes 3 specific models, noted by a number on the sticker. Of my three sets of 3 ton stands, only one set was recalled. I brought back the affected set and took a replacement.

harbor-freight-pittsburgh-stand-recall


The Split:

103420426_10158746850342112_4728047096448636706_o
This Photo is circulating of post-recall stand split on the seam.

A short while after the Recall, a mysterious photo of a split jack stand popped up on the internet and spread like WILDFIRE. The posts and memes are exploding again. The mysterious photo was credited to someone named Mike G, who was kind enough to respond to my messages on Instagram. Mike replied that the split occurred as soon as he lowered his VW Golf down onto the stands, on a smooth, flat concrete garage floor. I’ll take Mike for his word (I was skeptical until he sent me more pics). I am happy that no injury or property damage occurred, but I believe one failure is far from a whole new round of failures and recalls.

I am very curious to hear the opinion of any engineering/welding experts who can take a look at the failed unit, which seems to have broken by the weld separating from the metal on one side. Mike was able to share some more posts of the Stand, scroll down to see for yourself:

Below is a photo of a YouTube advertisement for a jack company video where the presenter explains his opinion of how poorly these stands are made. He then goes on a sales pitch for another brand (Including a prominently displayed coupon code in the description).

jack-stand-split-failing-harbor-freight-pittsburgh

The video claims that “This harbor freight jack stand is also failing” then explains why he believes the Jack Stand is built incorrectly.  There are certainly design and construction methods on the Harbor Freight Jack Stand that compromise overall strength for easy, cheap production. But at what load does the design become an actual issue? Will these fail at 3.1 tons, 6 tons, 10 tons, 20 tons? I looked through my older stands, and the construction “Issues” claimed in this video are present on all my stands (Including my 10 year old stands). I am all for supporting good, American companies who create high quality products… however, I don’t think it’s fair or reasonable to exaggerate dangers as a sales pitch.

IMG_20200611_133423
Some of my old non-recalled Stands: Note: “Big Red” (Not Harbor Freight) stands are constructed in the same way as the split unit in question. Remember: Most cheap jack stands are either identical units with a different sticker slapped on, or are at least, similarly produced. So however you feel, don’t expect much improvement with the $30 set from Home Depot or your local auto parts store.

 

I’m interested to see how this all plays out. Will we see more failures? Was this failure forced?  In the meantime I will continue to use my Harbor Freight Jack Stands, Both my new post-recall set and my old, pre-recall sets. I will also continue to give any vehicle a “shake test” before crawling underneath. Remember to always follow best practices when raising a vehicle, Stay safe out there!

In the meantime I will continue to use my Harbor Freight Jack Stands

I’ll leave you with this:

Harbor-Freight-Jack-Stand-Split-Breaking
Photo taken for Illustrative purposes. I did not crush my new stand, but if someone wants to try it for science, let me know I’d love photos and video.

Here are some more photos of the broke stand: What do you think?


Like what you saw here? Check out other posts on my site to learn more about No Money Motorsports, and get YOURSELF out on track!

ThisCanBeYouRacingAtWatkinsGlenRaceway

 

1 Comment

  1. From a mechanical engineer with a design and manufacturing background the failure looks legitimate. Its displays all the signs of the one side of the part not getting hot enough during the welding process and the molten metal just laid on the surface instead of actually welding. Common failure when things aren’t setup correctly.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s